Wednesday, February 13, 2013

Quick Fix is On!

Once again, we are travelling down the road looking for a quick fix!
As a cardiologist I typically shy away from endorsing any particular diet for my patients, limiting my advice to avoidance of saturated fats and concentrated sweets, and promoting physical activity. I do comment often on relative merits of various diet approaches but, in all fairness, the evidence of their full cardiovascular impact is limited. I have never advised anyone to seek weight-loss drugs yet one of them is making the front page news on www.heart.org today. The new drug (Qsymia, a combination of phentermine and topiramate) has been shown to improve cardiovascular risk factors (lipids and hypertension) in mildly to significantly obese subjects as determined by their BMI. The response was dose-related, and changes in risk factors did correlate with magnitude of the weight loss, being greater in those achieving >5% decrease in their baseline weight.
In my mind, here are the problems: the major component of this medication is a stimulant that may cause adverse cardiac events (post-marketing survey trial to monitor that is mandated by the FDA from the manufacturer), and the effects will likely disappear once medication is stopped, or, as it is the case with stimulants, the body will get used to it reducing its efficacy over time. Moreover, it is unlikely that a short-term reduction in risk factor burden will mitigate cardiovascular morbidity and mortality. The risk adjustment is a process that should take place over decades, as studies show that levels of risk factors measured as early as age 9 are already predictive of events in adulthood. And while it is commendable that those with obesity and risk factors undertake steps to reduce their impact, their lifestyle rather than the drugs is of paramount importance. Reasonable diet and daily exercise continue to be major factors impacting longevity, and greatly contributing to decreasing risk of cardiac events, including death. This effect is permanent for as long as such lifestyle continues, and devoid of side-effects! It had also been proven to work in multiple studies. As a side note, BMI is a rather poor measure of visceral fat which is the main contributor to cardiac events. Waist circumference is a much stronger  predictor, and anyone engaged in a fitness program already knows how hard it is to shrink this particular area! Too bad we can't mandate that drug makers enroll just as many patients into a supervised diet and exercise program to show non-inferiority of this approach to a drug! Perhaps, the FDA should do that?

Saturday, February 9, 2013

Winter weight off!

Lets be honest:
Winter means weight gain. For most of us it starts insidiously, with that extra piece of pie at Thanksgiving, only to be exponentially multiplied by excesses at Christmas/Hanukkah/Kwanza and New year celebrations! Add a week or two of vacation, and here you have it: 15 lbs up and counting!
Add to this the cold and les day light, and we are just about to reach the size of a hibernating bear!
All my friends have complain of the winter weight gain-is it really the norm for women in their 40s?
Actually, YES:
BUT, IT SHOULD NOT BE PERMANENT!
You must be willing to accept that your metabolism is not the same as it were in your 20s.
The challenge of weight loss involves incorporating your body's physiology into your plan. I will hit the  pluses and minuses of common diets using my very own and my patients experiences in future posts. Feel free to contribute with your story!